Skip to content

Help

Google Ads optimization score: why 100% can cost you money

By the SpendCanary team · Updated

At a glance

  • Google calls the score an estimate of how well your account is set to perform, from 0 to 100%. (source)
  • You can reach 100% by applying or dismissing all recommendations, so dismissing counts too. (source)
  • Optimization score is not used by your Quality Score. (source)

The Google Ads optimization score is a percentage, from 0 to 100%, that Google calls “an estimate of how well your account is set to perform”. In practice, it shows how many of Google’s current recommendations you have acted on, weighted by how much Google expects each one to help. It measures adoption of Google’s suggestions, not profit, and several of the suggestions that raise it most also raise how much you spend.

You can reach 100% without applying anything you disagree with: Google counts a dismissed recommendation the same way as an applied one. That is the safe route for any suggestion that widens your reach before you have the numbers to back it.

What does the optimization score measure?

Google describes it as “an estimate of how well your Google Ads account is set to perform”, where 100% means your account “can perform at its full potential”. It is calculated in real time from your account’s statistics, settings and status, the likely impact of the recommendations on offer, and your recent history with them. Trends across Google Ads can move it too, so the score can drop when you have changed nothing.

A few details that matter:

  • It is shown for active Search, Display, Video Action, App, Performance Max, Demand Gen and Shopping campaigns, at campaign, account and manager account level.
  • Each recommendation shows a score uplift, from under 0.1% up to 100%: how many points the score would gain if you acted on it.
  • Google says the score and its recommendations focus on your business goals, such as conversions or conversion value. They do not look at your profit margin, the value of a phone call, or whether last month’s leads turned into paying jobs.
  • “Optimization score is not used by your Quality Score.” A low score doesn’t lower your Quality Score.

You’ll find the score at the top of the Recommendations page, under Campaigns in the left menu.

Why can a higher score cost you more?

Because some recommendations are, in effect, invitations to spend more or to show your ads in more places. Google’s own descriptions say so. Here are the ones that most often push spend up, with Google’s wording for each:

  • “Raise your budgets”: “Keep your ads running on your busiest days by fixing your limited budget.” That is a straight increase in spend. Before you accept, check whether the campaign brings leads at a cost you’re happy with; if it doesn’t, a limited budget is protecting you.
  • “Add broad match keywords”: “Get more conversions at a similar or better ROI by adding broad match versions of your existing keywords.” Broad match shows your ads for loosely related searches, and Google itself says it’s critical to pair broad match with Smart Bidding.
  • “Bid more efficiently with Maximize conversions”: Google says Maximize Conversions “will try to fully spend your average daily budget” and “could increase spend significantly” if you currently spend well below your budget. It also needs conversion tracking; with only a handful of conversions it has little to learn from. See Maximize Clicks vs Maximize Conversions.
  • “Bid more efficiently with Maximize clicks”: it buys as many clicks as the budget allows, not customers.
  • “Expand your reach with Google search partners”: “Reach additional customers at a lower CPC on YouTube and partner sites.” Cheaper clicks are not cheaper leads; check your own numbers on the search partners page first.
  • “Use Display Expansion”: “Get more conversions at a similar CPA using unspent budget.” Unspent budget is money you were not spending before. Display clicks behave very differently from search clicks; see Display Network in a Search campaign.

Here’s how the Maximize Conversions one plays out. Say a Search campaign has a $30 daily budget and has been spending about $22 a day. Switching to Maximize Conversions lets Google aim for the full $30, an extra $8 a day, or about $240 a month, before you know whether those extra clicks bring work. The score goes up the day you click Apply. Whether your profit goes up is a separate question that only your own leads and sales can answer.

Which recommendations are usually safe?

Housekeeping ones that tidy the account without widening where your ads show or what you pay for:

  • “Remove redundant keywords” and “Remove non-serving keywords”;
  • “Remove conflicting negative keywords” (a negative that blocks one of your own keywords);
  • “Fix your conversion tracking” and “Set up enhanced conversions”, which improve what Google learns from; see setting up conversion tracking;
  • “Turn on auto-tagging”;
  • adding sitelink, callout and call assets, which give your ad more to show without changing who sees it.

Even these deserve a look before you apply. Google notes that new keywords may need review before they can show, and that the changes you apply appear in Change history, where you can undo most of them within 30 days.

Our rule: apply a recommendation when you would have made the change anyway. Dismiss it when it adds networks, loosens match types, switches bidding or raises the budget, unless your own last 30 to 90 days of results say the campaign can take more money. If you’re unsure about a bid or budget change, Google lets you Save as experiment to test it against your current setup.

How do I dismiss recommendations safely?

  1. Go to Campaigns > Recommendations.
  2. Open the card with View recommendation.
  3. If it doesn’t fit your business, select Dismiss all, on the card or under its 3-dot menu.

Your score rises as if you had applied it, and nothing changes in your campaigns. Three things to know:

  • Dismissals don’t last forever. Google says a recommendation can reappear after a set period, 30 or 60 days depending on the reason, if the campaign is still eligible. Check the page once a month.
  • Dismissing at campaign level hides that type only for that campaign. Dismiss at account level to hide it everywhere.
  • Changed your mind? Select the Dismissed bubble at the top of the Recommendations page, open the card’s 3-dot menu and choose Undismiss all.

How does auto-apply affect the score?

Auto-apply lets Google apply chosen recommendation types for you, checking daily which ones are eligible. Applying is one of the two ways the score goes up, so an account with auto-apply on can show a high score that nobody on your side earned. Google says auto-apply won’t raise your budget, but the eligible types include broad match keywords, search partners, Display expansion and bid strategy switches, which can all change how fast the budget goes.

If you’d rather decide yourself, see how to turn off auto-apply recommendations. It also shows where to find what auto-apply already changed.

Why do Google reps keep asking about it?

The score sits at the top of the Recommendations page, so it’s easy to point at on a call. Agencies have a reason of their own: Google requires a Google Partners registered manager account to have “a minimum optimization score of 70%” to keep the Partner badge. Google adds that “you’re in control, with the ability to apply or dismiss recommendations”, so a good agency can keep the score up by dismissing what doesn’t fit. Anyone who suggests applying everything is talking about the score, not your margin. Ask what each change is expected to do to your cost per lead, and dismiss what they can’t answer.

For a wider comparison of Google’s suggestions and an outside check, see Google Ads recommendations vs SpendCanary.

The free SpendCanary scan looks at the same settings from the other side. It flags auto-applied changes from the last 30 days that switched on search partners, Display, broad match or Maximize Clicks, and puts a dollar figure on search partner or Display spend that brought no conversions or cost at least twice as much per conversion as Google Search.

Sources

Common questions

Does a low optimization score hurt my ads?
Google says optimization score is not used by your Quality Score. A low score means there are recommendations you have not applied or dismissed, not that your ads are penalised.
Do paused campaigns count towards the optimization score?
No. Google shows the score for active Search, Display, Video Action, App, Performance Max, Demand Gen and Shopping campaigns only.
Do dismissed recommendations come back?
Yes. Google says a dismissed recommendation can reappear after a set period, 30 or 60 days depending on the reason you gave, if the campaign is still eligible.
Is it safe to click Apply all?
Not as a habit. Apply all applies every recommendation of that type at once. Open each one first, and only apply what you would have done anyway.