Is Thumbtack worth it? Lead prices, refunds and matching
By the SpendCanary team · Updated
At a glance
- You set your own Thumbtack lead price, and it’s the exact amount you pay for each lead. (source)
- Thumbtack refunds a lead automatically if the customer replies to no pro within 72 hours and you replied within 4 business hours. (source)
- Thumbtack doesn’t refund a lead because the customer hired a different pro. (source)
Is Thumbtack worth it? It is when its leads win you jobs at a lower cost per job than your other channels, and that depends mostly on how fast you reply and how big your jobs are. You set your own price per lead, but you still pay when the customer hires someone else, and two settings, smart matching and lead boosts, can bring leads outside your preferences or past your budget. Here’s how it all works, from Thumbtack’s own help pages.
How much does Thumbtack cost per lead?
Thumbtack doesn’t publish a price list. It says its goal is “to make the cost match how valuable the job is”, so prices vary with the type and size of the job, how many pros are available and your market.
You pay in one of three ways:
- Leads. A customer finds you in search results and contacts you, and the job matches your job preferences. You pay automatically. You set the price per service with a slider under Services, then Manage lead prices, and Thumbtack says it’s the exact amount you pay. As you move the slider, Thumbtack estimates how many leads you can expect.
- Opportunities (also called open leads). Customers who’ve contacted other pros but haven’t hired anyone. The price is shown upfront, you pay only if the customer responds to you, and it doesn’t come out of your weekly budget. An Opportunity closes after 48 hours or once five pros have shown interest.
- Preset jobs. Pre-scheduled jobs with no upfront cost; Thumbtack keeps a percentage of the job price as a fee. They’re for pros who meet certain criteria, such as having three or more reviews.
Two more things affect what you pay. Your lead price is only one of the factors behind how many leads you get, along with your profile, your star rating and reviews, how quickly you respond and local demand. And Thumbtack may raise its minimum lead prices: if yours are at or near the minimum, they may go up automatically. Thumbtack says it will tell you when that happens.
How does the Thumbtack weekly budget work?
Your budget is roughly what you’ll spend on leads in a week, across all your services. Once you pass it, you stop getting new leads until it resets on Monday.
The catch is the last lead. If it costs more than what’s left, you pay the full lead price, which can take you over budget by up to 40% of the budget or $40 plus 2% of it, whichever is less. On Thumbtack’s own table, that’s up to $40 over on a $100 budget, $45 on $250 and $50 on $500. You can also choose an unlimited budget, which has no weekly limit at all.
What are smart matching and lead boosts?
These two features add leads beyond your usual settings. As of November 2026, Thumbtack’s help pages describe them like this:
- Smart matching. You may get leads outside your job preferences when Thumbtack’s AI predicts they’re a strong fit, and you’re charged for them automatically. If one is a job you don’t do, decline it, choose Not what I do and explain why, and Thumbtack refunds it. Be careful: that answer changes the leads you get in future, so if you’d still want that kind of job, pick another reason such as Location or Not available. To get only exact matches again, turn off the Smart matching toggle on your Services page.
- Lead boosts. If you’re eligible, Thumbtack turns them on for you. After you reach your weekly budget, you can get extra leads that match your preferences at 25% off, on top of the budget: up to one extra lead for each paid lead you got that week before reaching it. Decline one before you reply and it’s refunded automatically. Turn them off with the Lead boosts toggle on your Services page.
If your weekly spend matters more than the number of leads, check both toggles. With lead boosts on, a week can cost more than the budget you set.
Can I get a refund from Thumbtack?
Some refunds are automatic, others are decided case by case, and some situations are never refunded.
Automatic refunds. Thumbtack’s Fair Shot Refund applies if the customer replies to no pro within 72 hours of their request. To qualify, you must have accepted the lead and replied within four business hours (8am to 8pm your time), made your first contact through Thumbtack’s messenger or a Thumbtack number, and not shared your own phone number or email before the customer’s first reply. A customer calling you counts as a reply, even if you don’t pick up. Leads flagged by Thumbtack’s Trust and Safety team, smart match leads you decline, and lead boosts you decline before replying are refunded automatically too.
Case by case, within 45 days of the charge. Thumbtack says these will most likely qualify:
- the job changed significantly, for example to a location outside your travel area;
- an Opportunity customer’s first reply is a clear no;
- the lead breaks Thumbtack’s terms of use;
- a fixed date you’d already blocked in your calendar;
- a disconnected or invalid phone number;
- the same customer and identical job within 45 days, or a double charge.
Not refunded. A customer who hired a different pro. Thumbtack’s refund policy is clear: “we don’t provide refunds in these situations”. Prepaid credit packages aren’t refundable either, and all refunds are at Thumbtack’s “sole discretion”.
Refunds go to your Thumbtack balance. To get one back on your card instead, contact Thumbtack within 10 business days of the approval. Thumbtack usually answers a request within 24 to 48 hours, and up to four days if it needs more review.
Is Thumbtack worth it for your business?
Work it out per job won, not per lead. Here’s an example with our own numbers, not Thumbtack prices. Say you set a $40 lead price and get 10 leads in a month: $400. Two customers never reply to anyone, and because you answered within four business hours on Thumbtack, both are refunded: $320. You win 2 jobs, so each job cost you $160. If you’d replied slowly, there would be no refunds and each job would cost $200.
Now compare that with what a job costs you elsewhere. If a Google Ads lead costs you $90 and you win 1 in 3, a Google job costs $270, and Thumbtack is cheaper. If you win only 1 Thumbtack job from those 10 leads, it costs $320, and Google is cheaper. Our is Angi worth it guide uses the same method for Angi and Local Services Ads.
Track 8 to 12 weeks, with Thumbtack’s own number or messenger for Thumbtack customers and a separate tracked number for each other channel (see call tracking). Then:
- Keep it if its cost per job won, with refunds taken off, is at or below your other channels, and you can reply within four business hours. Speed is what wins jobs and qualifies you for refunds.
- Cut it, or cut your lead prices, if many leads come from customers who hire someone else, or if your jobs are small enough that one lead price is a large share of what you’d earn.
Pros giving up on lead services is a theme in our count of Reddit comments from local trades, in the box at the end of this guide and on how local trades lose customers.
If you also run Google Ads, the same question applies there: are you paying for clicks that can’t become jobs? The free SpendCanary scan checks your Google Ads account for wasted spend, such as clicks from outside your area and search terms you don’t serve. It doesn’t look at Thumbtack.
Sources
- Thumbtack Help: Paying for leads and Opportunities, Setting lead prices, Types of leads, Opportunities, Weekly budget, Smart Match leads, Lead boosts, Refund policy, Fair Shot Refunds, Quality Commitment, Quality Commitment terms (last updated 28 September 2026).
- Reddit counts: our own count of comments from local trades, January to June 2026, on our data page.
- Thumbtack is a trademark of its owner. Its rules change; we checked these pages on 20 November 2026. The $40 lead price, the close rates and the $90 Google Ads lead are our own illustration.
Common questions
- Does Thumbtack refund a lead if the customer hires someone else?
- No. Thumbtack’s refund policy says it doesn’t give refunds when the customer hires a different pro.
- How do I stop Thumbtack charging me for leads outside my preferences?
- Turn off Smart matching on your Services page. For a smart match lead you already got, decline it and choose Not what I do, and Thumbtack refunds it.
- Why did Thumbtack charge me after I reached my budget?
- Either the last lead took you over your budget, which Thumbtack allows up to a limit, or lead boosts are on and sent you extra leads at 25% off. You can turn lead boosts off on your Services page.